“BONANZA!”
“AND IF THAT MAP BURNS, IT’LL BE A GREECE FIRE.”
Is this the Herc movie with “I’m long” at the beginning? I get them all mixed up? But I like that riff because of how common smushing up widescreen was before HDTV.
I think when this movie was edited to fit into the show’s time slot, some critical exposition must have been lost in the process. Because it’s not all that clear how the bulk of these scenes link together. Near as I can tell, Hercules goes to Atlantis for undisclosed reasons, at least in this cut. Of course, it’s ruled by an evil queen and they have the misfortune of having Uranus as their patron deity. Obviously, this would have been a non-issue in the original Italian but gets very unfortunate in English. Especially when the high priest starts talking about the blood of Uranus. Perhaps if the English dub actors had pronounced it with a short A. This also features a somewhat nebbish Hylas, who in mythology is a companion of Hercules but here is presented as his son.
So I’ve been going through the archives of It’s Just a Show. So far, it’s not bad. But one aspect that grates my cheese is their smug assertion that the SciFi era was a descent into senility for the series. Does anyone ever write in to tell them what a load of horse hoo that is (that they acknowledge anyway)? If not, I may have to send in a polite but firmly worded email detailing why their assertion is flawed.
You’re confusing this with Hercules Unchained (1959). The opening titles of Unchained is where the “I’m Long” jokes are. They made laugh when I last watched it.
REAL TALK: GPC had a solid riff in the theater with “Hey, get this, they’re steam cleaning the horses,” but she had a much better riff with “Oh, they found a fun friend!” as some guys pull the little person into the frame.
She evolved as she sat those few minutes. Utter happiness and excitement chased by the novelty of chiming in on a movie and her inaugural riffs were obvious and “Oh, they found a fun friend!” nodded she was improving and Crow and Tom didn’t complain. She had become one of the gang. “Hey, get this, they’re steam cleaning the horses” is the peak of her riffing and her involvement in the movie and after that she loses interest and eventually leaves. “Fun friend” is the more relaxed riff and highly indicative of the show but I must profess a weakness for the “steam cleaning” line. It is so Gypsy. The fun friend could have been said by the others.
I hadn’t actively considered this, but I love this interpretation of her time in the theater.
Post “steam cleaning”, the prophesy scene lands and we see her taking it in but not responding. The badness of the movie sets in and she then says “Um, you guys, you know um, this movie’s really not good.” She suddenly has things to do and she’s gone. A five minute mini-arc within the riff of the movie.

As for the episode in general: It’s not bad. It’s easily the most chopped-up of the Herc movies featured, so it can get really difficult to understand at times. But those great, colorful production values are still there. Joel and The Bots are reliable because the movie is always throwing something in their direction.
This is a solid episode in a great season!
Season 4 rises to the top. So many strong episodes. The variability, the adversity, the finesse, Space Travelers (1969) to Monster a Go-Go (1965) to Manos: The Hands of Fate (1966). Mystery Science Theater hardened as an expression of culture and comedy into something that would last. And you really caught that during this season.
412 is both midpoint and a prime sample of playing with the form (Gypsy in the theater) and having it land. They were really coming into their own and the tell is how consistent every episode is. The movies were about to get worse and Joel and the Bots would be ready for them. In spades.
When it comes to Hercules movies, I’m with Gypsy.
And of course that one also has Ettori Mani’s great gams, and that priest who looks like he looted the dressing room of an Earth, Wind, and Fire concert.(Oh, and all the Herc-Hylas father-son jokes.)
The riff, “Sorry, I thought you were someone I used to date,” is on-target. Herc and Androcles totally do bicker like exes.
Great episode.
Still not trying the raw goat, though.
Gypsy turning up in the theater was fun. They genuinely were trying to expand her personality.
As far as the Toga and Sandals Fantasy flicks go, this was fairly typical of what they entailed. Lots of pomp, lots of padding, lots of cheesy side events.
One thing I’ve always liked about the Hercules episodes is that they all had A-level budgets. Production Design, Visual Effects, etc. (Well, maybe not Hercules Against the Moonmen.) Except for maybe Space Travelers and some of the Soviet fairy tale flicks, most of the productions featured on MST wore their low budgets on their sleeves. It’s just nice to see some genuine spectacle sometimes.
The spectacle is fine. The endless padding, especially with dance scenes, not so much.
Good point.
Yeah, I find her experience in this episode to be relatable, since, I’m not good at riffing either, even when I want to give Super Mario Sunshine’s voice acting the riffing treatment.