I’m getting a little tired of when I quote someone’s post that isn’t terribly long and my post gets auto-edited to remove the quote. I quote those for a reason, you know! Is there any way to turn that functionality off?
I think it only does that when your post follows directly after the one you’re quoting. To make threads cleaner looking, I guess.
True
But if you only do a partial quote (like I just did), it’ll leave that be.
Yeah, I’ve discovered if I leave off the last bit of punctuation, the forum won’t “help” by removing the quote. It is bloody annoying though.
It kinda makes sense though, right? If my post quotes the post immediately above it, that is a bit redundant. I’d be fine if it was switched off, but I can see the thinking behind it.
But when a reply is right below, the “this is what I replied to” indicator also doesn’t show so it’s extra unclear if it’s a reply to a reply or a reply to the main post.
I’m replying to one of you. Can you tell who? I’m not touching you!
Good point. The problem must exist for other forums as well, but it probably doesn’t help that everything here is a “reply” to something else. I think turning off the auto-editing might indeed be the best solution.
Pro-tip: When you quote all of someone’s comment, you’ll see this:
[quote=“Brina, post:1, topic:18296, full:true”]
I’m getting a little tired of when I quote someone’s post that isn’t terribly long and my post gets auto-edited to remove the quote. I quote those for a reason, you know! Is there any way to turn that functionality off?
[/quote]
If you remove the full:true, the post will not be elided, e.g.:
I quoted McCloud in full here and (he said hopefully) the full quote remains.
Ah. That explains the problem I’ve been having. I use the reply button so the person knows I responded and others can see that it is a direct response. Sometimes, even though the new post is directly below the one I’m replying to, the fact that it is a direct reply is relevant context. It’s been frustrating to see that indicator repeatedly stripped away without warning.
Quoting something will add back the context, unless you quote it all. Then it’ll be stripped again and you have to edit and re quote again.
Yup. I tried quoting people for that exact reason and just had it auto edited out of my reply. So I had to go edit the post to make it make sense again. As much as I ever make sense, anyway.
Leave out a character (such as a period) when you quote the post above. Then the software will leave it in place.
Not sure encouraging people to change what’s quoted is an ideal programming system.
I wholly agree!
Me too!