It used to be on YouTube, but not anymore apparently. Oh well, I kept saying I would get around to it, but it’s too late now.
Psst…It’s still there…
I’ve been rewatching the SciFi era but had to put a pause in there when my Gizmoplex pooped out just as I got to this episode. Very happy to report that I got the app back up and running and just watched this again last night. It’s never been one of my favorites, but it has grown on me over time. I’ve always loved the host segments with the poo throwing, Brain Guy and Pearl’s duet and, of course, Pearl’s fundraising shtick.
Glad you got the app issues figured out! What finally worked?
My ex once said that Julia looked like he was waiting for the director to actually direct, and I can see where he was coming from. It’s very much a project that had the wrong director.
I have an uncut and unMSTed copy of this, and while the story is a lot better… I’ve also read the original John Varley novella. Now, I have never understood what it is that drives screenwriters and/or directors to say, “Oh, hey, look, here’s this great story, let’s film it but change everything so that it’s not the story anymore!” (see in particular: the I, Robot movie (on the trailer for which I nearly walked out of the theater), any of the three versions of Nightfall, or the Foundation series—do you sense a little bitterness about the way Asimov has been treated by movies and TV?)
What they filmed (or rather videotaped) was not Varley’s Overdrawn at the Memory Bank, except in the broadest possible of terms.
My advice to screenwriters and directors is: it’s not YOUR zarking story, you’re supposed to be realizing someone else’s vision. Tell the one that’s actually there, don’t make up some nonsense and then slap the name on it. If you want to tell a different story, then grow up and put your own name on your own story, don’t pretend you’re “adapting” something that’s almost certainly better than anything you could write.
Yeah, just a little bitter over three failed Nightfalls, one failed I, Robot, and a Foundation that I refuse to discuss…
Reset the router in the main house. (I live in a cottage in the back.) I feel like a dumbass. I was having the same issues with the Rifftrax and Disney+ apps but everything else worked fine. I’m glad that’s over with though!
A brilliant cameo!
Oh man, I nearly threw my shoe at the screen during I, Robot. (I was wearing my Chuck Taylor Converse and the product placement for those shoes and some car I can’t remember was beyond annoying.) I remember reading an interview with someone involved with the making of the movie Wanted - it was probably the director - and the dude was so proud of the fact that the movie he made had absolutely nothing but the bare bones and the title to do with the comic that it was based on. I loved that comic and can’t remember a time I was more angry at the blatant disregard by Hollywood for the source material. (Then came JJ Abrams and Star Trek but we won’t go there because Jon Stewart said what needed to be said to his face.)
Hollywood has only very recently learned that fans of a thing probably want adaptations of that thing to bear more than a passing resemblance to that thing, and that the charm of that thing will draw the audience to come to love the thing without needing to change the thing into what Hollywood thinks an audience wants a movie to be.
The I, Robot movie was not intended to be an adaptation of I, Robot. That was executive meddling.
Then it should’ve been called something else.
I mean, if I helmed a movie called Lensman that borrowed a couple characters and ideas from Doc Smith and then made something that had nothing to do with any of his stories and also used the characters and ideas in ways that were contradictory to canon, I a) should not call it Lensman and b) deserve what approbation I get if I do. Nor would I expect to escape complaint if I made a movie called The War of the Worlds that was about a future civil war between Earth-based and Moon-based humans.
There are expectations that go with well-known titles. I would have no complaint if it had been called something else, but what they made was in no way, shape or form I, Robot. I think it borders closely on false advertising.
This episode does contain my all-time favorite riff: “Whup, I’m fartin’ Monopoly cards!”
I know, I’m a five year old sometimes. XD
Oh, so Fingal wasn’t a creepy, murdering, entitled lech (who tried to model his meaningless life on a fictional character who he didn’t even understand) in the original story? That makes me feel a little better.
The original was a lot more thoughtful – I’ll have to dig it out again, I haven’t read it in a while. Oddly enough, one of the few scenes in the movie that was from the novella was the whole “Venus on the Half Shell” sequence.
Oh, I agree completely. In this case, what happened was that an executive had a script for a totally different robot movie, realized they had the rights to I, Robot and told a punch-up doctor to throw in a few Asimov references and call it a day. Don’t blame the crew in this case.
Oh no. I lay the blame squarely at the feet of director Alex Proyas, and writers Jeff Vintar and Akiva Goldsman (the latter of whom I consider to be the Jack Kevorkian of script doctors).
It took a LOT of work to find, I have new admiration for Fingle, that was the movie in full. OMG, so much better. I haven’t read the book. In many cases the book is better. I couldn’t follow Tolkien in either format. In their defense some things are too fantastic to get into a movie when it was made. We’re talking about a time when 8-bit games were high tech. My mind was blown over 16-bit games. (I think my hair just turned grey.)
For reference my mobile is 6 GB, approximately 6 billion little biddy bytes. That’s about 750 million original NES machines.
Wanna sell it to someone who will watch and enjoy it.
Really? Cuz the way I’ve seen it lately, Hollywood likes to call the existing fanbase “toxic” to guard themselves against any criticism for changes or defamation of established characters.
They already have fans in their pockets who will see anything that has their favorite stamp on it so they make something they think will attract new people which usually appeals to no one
But that’s just my opinion and I’m drinking wine