I just watched K01 yesterday while building a chair, and I’m glad I had something to occupy me, because the jokes were like one every 3-5 minutes on that episode. Joel doesn’t even enter the theater until like 2 minute into the film. The jokes pacing picks up a bit when Crow joins him halfway through the film, but it’s still far slower on the jokes than even season 1 on Comedy Channel. They’re also not necessarily the sharpest jokes, but due to the improv nature, often the simplest obvious jokes. Like, Joel repeats a “pull my finger” gag 3-4 times through the episode.
I can see the appeal the show had when it first aired, since the episode has the feel of watching a cheesy movie on TV with your roommates, especially with both Crow and Joel entering and leaving the theater at random point. Crow even asks “what did I miss?” a few times. At the time, the show was basically a bonus over just watching a b-movie on its own, which was a common practice for many, but it doesn’t hold a candle to the later joke-loaded episodes. Likewise, with the host segments, they’re ok, but the bots act very differently and there’s not a lot to them. To me, the episode has interest as a historical artifact of a show I like, but this episode is not likely to get many rewatches from me, if at all.
In terms of the show remaking them, aside from the monetary costs, one has to consider the time and effort in just taking the time to refilm them, which would take away time they have to make all-new episodes or shorts. Also, I don’t think Joel is all that enthused about these episodes. Like, he’s proud in one sense in that they’re the origin of the show, but also a much weaker version of the show before they figured everything out and hit their grove. They’re like a rough draft; necessary to get to the final work, but not necessarily something one wants to share with the whole world.
Likewise, I think for the fans, the KTMA episode are a niche within a niche. I’ve been watching the show since the Comedy Channel years, but I never sat down and watched a full KTMA episode until yesterday, and I wasn’t impressed. So I think to suddenly spring on most fans a “new” episode that’s a much slower pace and more scattered in joke delivery would lead to a lot of confusion and questioning of why the show was releasing these.
I’m all for preserving, and even remastering the KTMA episodes to provide them in as high as quality as possible, but I think remaking them as-is would be going to far. I am fine with them redoing a movie from that era though.