- Season 1
- Season 2
- Season 3
- Season 4
- Season 5
- Season 6
- Season 7
- Season 8
- Season 9
- Season 10
- Season 11
- Season 12
- Season 13
0 voters
0 voters
Wait. Uh… you want out Top 3 but we can only actually choose two ?
I’m SO lost. :o
Yep, I messed that up. Should be fixed now. Sorry!
It’s still showing as 2 for me. Dagnabbit!
But I’m willing to go on record with my all-time favorite as Season 5, without question. You get both our founding hosts more or less in equal measure. What’s not to love?
I’ll reveal my choices as well:
Season Five has the broadest range of movies featured and, as mentioned, the historic change of hosts!
Season Eight is just a very strong season all-around!
Five and Eight
Then Seven and Six
Nothing brilliant to add to that.
Edit - yeesh, typos, man, where is my mind.
Season Five was in God Mode, plain and simple.
I voted for 8 and 11. Both had time and opportunity to really swing for the fences in their first season on a new channel (as it were), and knocked them out of the park with great movie choices and riffs. Seasons 3, 4 and 5 are tied for 3rd.
For second place? I have Seasons 8 and 11 tied.
Both are so wonderful and represent the heights that MST3K is capable of.
I picked season 6 and season 9, but I wanted to have season 4 as well.
Seasons 4 and 8. Picking a third would have been impossible between 2, 3, 5, 6, and 11.
4 and 6. The biggest concentration of hilarious episodes. 13 is off to a great start, and could be a contender.
I’m glad others are voting for season 4. That way I can pretend I did, too.
I voted for seasons 5 and 7. Season 5 was great because it featured both Joel and Mike episodes. And Mike really started out strong. Some of his best episodes are in this season.
Season 7 is obviously really short, but it still has some great episodes. It’s also home to my favorite episode of the entire series, Laserblast. Quality over quantity.
Agonizing, but I went with 8 and 9 due to several of my favorite episodes appearing in both seasons. Seasons 3 and 6 were really close to making top two as well. The bronze tier (if we are doing two seasons per tier) would be 11 and 5.
6 and 9
Nice
Seven is very high for me. It’s the second shortest season but it’s all winners.