Source: Am a Hoosier. Sigh.
Geesh, I’d forgotten about that.
Also a Hoosier.
(the audio sync strays a bit by the end, but this was a conversion from a Flash file, so please handle it with grace)
- Chocolate
- Chocolate and Raspberry
- Chocolate and Peanut Butter
I’m sensing a theme …
What do I choose if I want strawberry rhubarb? That seems to be the go-to in my family.
I chose Cherry, however.
Honestly, there’s no wrong answer. Except sweet potato. That just seems weird.
It’s not, it’s delicious. Honestly. It’s a little like pumpkin pie.
Would it be in your top 10?
Probably not, but I wouldn’t turn it down at Thanksgiving (which is when I’ve had it in the past).
I’m kind of surprised about the current lack of popularity for cherry. Right now, it’s losing out to coconut cream by 3 to 1!
I was surprised to learn that there really is a honey pie. I thought that was just a term of endearment/Beatles song.
How about that mock apple pie made with Ritz crackers. Has any one tried that? How is it?
I assumed I would have seen at least one vote for chess pie by now, but those people may still be recovering from their most recent sugar crash.
As much as apple pie’s my favorite flavor, why’s there no love for chocolate cream pie?
We’re, of course, all familiar by now with the concept of “specialty breads”. I guess chocolate cream goes under the category of “specialty pies”, or “other” in our poll.
Sorry, I just didn’t think of it when I was trying to come up with pie types. I wasn’t sure how many choices I would be allowed to create in the poll, so I just put in the ones I thought of first. You are not the first one to mention chocolate, so clearly I missed the boat on that one. And I’m a big fan of chocolate in general, but not in pies I guess.
Though I went with Blackberry, it’s really Blackberry Cobbler that is my favorite. Strictly round pies (with upper and lower crusts), it’s Cherry Lattice first, Peach second, and Pumpkin third. I will accept Sweet Potato in lieu of Pumpkin, it’s tasty as well. And I agree with @SuperCutie, Chocolate Chess would be a nice option, but I also understand you want to avoid an infinite pie list.
I made it once way back in the day. It was underwhelming. To quote Frasier Crane, “Nothing spoils an apple pie like apples.”
Don’t make me forgive Pinterest for being Pinterest. It HURRRTS!!
I’m not a big sweets fan, so I went with the tart one: Key lime pie.
How am I the only one (thus far) who has voted for blueberry?!
Blueberry is the best, and that’s a hill I’m willing to die on.