Who would win in a fight- Hercules or Ator?

MST3K Central
1

Which bare-chested “hero” do you think would win?

6 Likes
2

Shouldn’t Conan be a part of this conversation?

Correction: Just noticed the MST3K Central classification. Apologies.

3 Likes
3

Is Herc taking a nap? That would give Ator an advantage.

7 Likes
4

Amazingly, he’s awake, so…

6 Likes
5

Are hang gliders permitted under the regulations and bylaws of this pugilistic competition?

6 Likes
6

My Cheesesteak puts them in a double headlock, gives a hearty cry of “ahhh, c’mere, ya rummies,” and bonks their noggins together, stealing a victory.

6 Likes
7

I nominate Maciste to be a third choice.

856×482 47 KB

4 Likes
8

4 different actors playing Hercules gives them a clear numbers advantage over 1 Miles O’Keeffe

7 Likes
9

One must ask. What about the Geometric Nucleus? That could be a gamechanger!

1024×768 238 KB

5 Likes
10

Wow I haven’t seen this thread since rec.arts.comics.whut

4 Likes
11

Strictly hand-to-hand, Hercules wins.

But if they’re allowed to McGyver up a weapon/distraction/trap, Ator wins.

7 Likes
12

Once The Herc uses that line, “So, the Mighty Ator needs a sword to defeat me,” Ator would naturally disarm himself, turning the fight into a wrestling match. Advantage Herc. But, wait! Ator grabs a handful of DIY gunpowder! What will happen next?

5 Likes
13

Remember Thong and Mila. They could help.

720×544 83 KB

3 Likes
14

But only in a cameo-style melee assist attack, like one of the Hyper Combos in Marvel Vs. Capcom.

3 Likes
15

For it’s worth. Ator wins if it’s brains and Herc wins if it’s a physical contest.

6 Likes
16

Imagine if Sandor could tag team.

3 Likes
17

If it’s Super Sloppy Double Dare, it could really go either way.

3 Likes
18

NOT THE LINKING RINGS COMBO, NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

3 Likes
19

And you would hear him say, “It is clearly there.”

3 Likes
20

And that’s his only line.

4 Likes