I’ll go with Garth Brooks covering Billy Joel’s “Shameless.” Billy’s version is good, but Garth gives it a vibrancy I love. Garth is a much better singer than I think people realize, and this one shows off his voice very well.
Go listen to that Al Green cover. Inserting that much soul into one of the Beatles’ least interesting songs makes it a better song in my opinion. And I find very few Beatles covers to be superior.
One of the least interesting. I mean compare it to the musical depth of any song on Sgt. Pepper. Compare it to Can’t Buy Me Love one year later for that matter. It’s a good song because I don’t think the Beatles ever did a bad song, but it’s not one of their best.
This is always the first one that springs to mind. Perfect blend of concept and execution.
For my money the drum pattern is one of the greatest compositional feats in the history of percussion (seriously, who thinks of something like that?) and actually performing it? Forget it!